Lovely food and atmosphere, but the quiz is more rigged than a North Korean election.
Adam B
£6 for a Madri and pub quizzes that don't let people play...This bar used to be good, but it's so, so dead now.
Victor Stoica
Cool bar with good music but kind of expensive
Clare Lonergan
On a hot humid Saturday afternoon, I had a ball. Delicious taco's, hats off to chef. Superb drinks, refreshing cocktail made by Jess. Lovely vibe, worth every penny x
James Williams
Seems as though the food choices have gone down drastically. The burritos used to be the main attraction and they no longer do these. The tacos we ordered were small (snack sized) and despite having separate orders they were all delivered on the same plates. Very unfortunate. Room for improvement.
Олена Шіхова
Nice place and great variety of beer. Just a message for the owner, do something with toilets, they're really old and dirty ?? Unpleasant to use wet toilet paper and wash hands with a leaking tap
toffeenosebooth
Person serving behind the bar was a mardy bum who openly sighed when asked what Gins they had and didn’t tell me the price of the round, just held out the card machine with disdain. I’m sorry that serving a couple of unstirred gins and mediocre pints in a near empty bar was such a massive hassle for him. Toilets are tiny and atmosphere is zero. I’ve written this review because I always forget how below average this bar is until I wander in approximately once a year thinking “why don’t I come here more?!” and then remember when I’m greeted with sub par drinks and service and a sticky floor.
Pete Wylie
Seeing people leave and the staff don't seem to want to clear the tables. Been here a hour, table full of leftover plates. Glasses on others. A jacket left on a seat. Obviously the staff don't care. Beer selection was okay. Cocane bag in the men's toilets, no cocanane in the bag, at least something gets cleaned out. Mid day Sunday
Leah McEwan
Visited today at lunchtime and had a really enjoyable experience. It was my first time eating here and the staff were really helpful and made some recommendations on food choices. Would definitely visit again :)
AMY ILICI
Got takeaway from here last night, first time. The food was ok but were all shocked by the portion sizes. Smallest burrito I've ever seen and it was £9? Taco's also disappointing. Compared to the other Mexican food places in Sheff I don't think it was worth the price and we won't be ordering again.
Just had a bottomless brunch at Gatsby and had the pleasure of having Hannah as our waitress! Food was delicious and the bar tender made the drinks to perfection! Thankyou so much to you all we will be back ♥️
Lisa Wright
Just been for a bottomless brunch here absolutely fantastic our bar tender hannah is absolutely amazing nothing to much trouble went above and beyond would definitely recommend amazing service and a great atmosphere definitely be back ?
Jane McPhillips
We had our Christmas party upstairs in the private room and had a lovely time. Staff were really attentive. As we had all pre ordered food I was dreading the usual “I can’t remember who ordered what” which drags out the night, I was pleasantly surprised when our food all started being served with our name, smooth, efficient and really tasty. As a vegan I was really impressed with the choice available and it was amazing. I’m going back just for the food! We had a quiz organised for us which was great fun and overall I couldn’t recommend highly enough. Get your Christmas do booked now!
Michael C
Wife and I went in early doors whilst Xmas shopping during the week. The food was excellent, if you are dashing then please remember They make good food as quickly as they can, They dont do fast food, The beer was super, a great range of real ales and interesting largers as well so nothing not to like. The staff were very helpful and truely could not find anything wrong. And the added bonus was that we had the two for one dining deal on the Burritos, will be going back when next in Sheffield.
LadySurfinRocker
Gatsby has a nice atmosphere although slightly dark. The staff were very friendly, but the service was terribly slow in serving the meal even though we were the only ones eating, However, can take nothing away from the meal itself which we delicious.
Lovely food and atmosphere, but the quiz is more rigged than a North Korean election.
£6 for a Madri and pub quizzes that don't let people play...This bar used to be good, but it's so, so dead now.
Cool bar with good music but kind of expensive
On a hot humid Saturday afternoon, I had a ball. Delicious taco's, hats off to chef. Superb drinks, refreshing cocktail made by Jess. Lovely vibe, worth every penny x
Seems as though the food choices have gone down drastically. The burritos used to be the main attraction and they no longer do these. The tacos we ordered were small (snack sized) and despite having separate orders they were all delivered on the same plates. Very unfortunate. Room for improvement.
Nice place and great variety of beer. Just a message for the owner, do something with toilets, they're really old and dirty ?? Unpleasant to use wet toilet paper and wash hands with a leaking tap
Person serving behind the bar was a mardy bum who openly sighed when asked what Gins they had and didn’t tell me the price of the round, just held out the card machine with disdain. I’m sorry that serving a couple of unstirred gins and mediocre pints in a near empty bar was such a massive hassle for him. Toilets are tiny and atmosphere is zero. I’ve written this review because I always forget how below average this bar is until I wander in approximately once a year thinking “why don’t I come here more?!” and then remember when I’m greeted with sub par drinks and service and a sticky floor.
Seeing people leave and the staff don't seem to want to clear the tables. Been here a hour, table full of leftover plates. Glasses on others. A jacket left on a seat. Obviously the staff don't care. Beer selection was okay. Cocane bag in the men's toilets, no cocanane in the bag, at least something gets cleaned out. Mid day Sunday
Visited today at lunchtime and had a really enjoyable experience. It was my first time eating here and the staff were really helpful and made some recommendations on food choices. Would definitely visit again :)
Got takeaway from here last night, first time. The food was ok but were all shocked by the portion sizes. Smallest burrito I've ever seen and it was £9? Taco's also disappointing. Compared to the other Mexican food places in Sheff I don't think it was worth the price and we won't be ordering again.
Restaurantji Recommends
Just had a bottomless brunch at Gatsby and had the pleasure of having Hannah as our waitress! Food was delicious and the bar tender made the drinks to perfection! Thankyou so much to you all we will be back ♥️
Just been for a bottomless brunch here absolutely fantastic our bar tender hannah is absolutely amazing nothing to much trouble went above and beyond would definitely recommend amazing service and a great atmosphere definitely be back ?
We had our Christmas party upstairs in the private room and had a lovely time. Staff were really attentive. As we had all pre ordered food I was dreading the usual “I can’t remember who ordered what” which drags out the night, I was pleasantly surprised when our food all started being served with our name, smooth, efficient and really tasty. As a vegan I was really impressed with the choice available and it was amazing. I’m going back just for the food! We had a quiz organised for us which was great fun and overall I couldn’t recommend highly enough. Get your Christmas do booked now!
Wife and I went in early doors whilst Xmas shopping during the week. The food was excellent, if you are dashing then please remember They make good food as quickly as they can, They dont do fast food, The beer was super, a great range of real ales and interesting largers as well so nothing not to like. The staff were very helpful and truely could not find anything wrong. And the added bonus was that we had the two for one dining deal on the Burritos, will be going back when next in Sheffield.
Gatsby has a nice atmosphere although slightly dark. The staff were very friendly, but the service was terribly slow in serving the meal even though we were the only ones eating, However, can take nothing away from the meal itself which we delicious.