Restaurants in Edinbane

Edinbane Lodge Old Dunvegan Road, Edinbane, Portree
Edinbane Lodge
Seafood • $$$$

Edinbane Lodge

Old Dunvegan Road, Edinbane, Portree

Extraordinary food, unforgettable people. We’d return to Scotland just for Edinbane Lodge.

Edinbane Lodge was spectacular. The food, the drinks, the breakfast, and above all, the people. Katie, Brody, Craig and chef Callum made our stay unforgettable, as did every member of the front-of-house team we met.

The staff were warm, inviting and wonderfully personable, the kind of people you would happily sit down and have a drink with. They combined that warmth with exceptional professionalism. Every drink we ordered was beautifully made and tasted exactly as it should. Dinner was extraordinary, and breakfast was another pleasure to look forward to.

Our room was lovely, clean and so comfortable, and I slept incredibly well. We had everything we needed to settle in and relax. As an interior designer, I especially appreciated the local Edinbane pottery used throughout the lodge and rooms, from the lamps to the cups and saucers. Those thoughtful, hyperlocal details made the whole place feel like a love letter to Skye.

What really stayed with us were the little interactions that made the experience feel personal. As US midwesterners (if you know you know and to the Edinbane staff we are sorry for our classic midwest goodbye), we know that memorable little interactions and engaging in small talk is an art, one that the staff either have a natural gift for or have carefully worked to craft.

During dinner, Josh and I were holding hands as Brody came to set down a plate. I joked that I was showing Josh what getting your cuticles trimmed during a manicure involves. The next morning, Brody remembered and made a playful comment about being able to put our breakfast down now that we weren’t holding hands. It was such a small, funny interaction, but so endearing. Those personal touches made us feel remembered and warmly welcomed.

Craig was exceptionally busy at the bar one evening, but when he delivered our drinks, he noticed our word game we were playing. I asked if he wanted to help, and he took a minute or two to play along. Those few moments meant so much. That is what exceptional hospitality looks like: making someone feel that you have time for them, even when you are busy.

At checkout, I asked about the beekeeper who supplied their honey. Katie offered to find her address and, when she couldn’t locate it, called Callum to the front to ask him while we checked out. He explained that he had the beekeeper’s last batch, then went to fetch us a jar to take home, free of charge. I had simply wanted to know where to buy it. Katie’s effort and Callum’s generosity were such a lovely way to end our stay.

And the shortbread! Delicious, and made even more special by the recipe provided to take home. Such a thoughtful detail.

We stayed at The Torridon afterwards, and Edinbane Lodge had set a standard it simply could not match. At every disappointing meal or service misstep, we found ourselves saying, “We wish we were still at Edinbane.” The difference in warmth, food and overall care was striking.

In our opinion, as avid fine dining folks, the restaurant deserves one or two Michelin stars, and the lodge deserves a Michelin Key based on the exemplary service provided and outstanding food. This is somewhere we would return to Skye specifically to experience again.

To Katie, Brody, Craig, Callum and the whole team: if you are reading this, we plan to come back and truly hope to see you all again. Thank you for giving us a stay we are still talking about with so much affection.

- Karoline and Josh

  • Drive-Through
  • Superb190 Reviews 4.7
Greshornish House Resturant Greshornish House Hotel, Edinbane, Portree
Greshornish House Resturant

Greshornish House Resturant

Greshornish House Hotel, Edinbane, Portree

Lovely discreet hotel down a quiet route on Skye - traditional well kept with lawned gardens and a great stay transiting to Harris. Staff( especially the girl from Birmingham ) were very friendly and helpful - lovely tasty evening meal served follow by a varied breakfast the next morning : expensive room was a bit small and hot over the kitchen : surprise was a golden pheasant walking past the breakfast room window !

  • Drive-Through
  • Superb26 Reviews 4.4

Discover More In Edinbane